INSIGHT AND FORESIGHT

July 28, 2014

PEOPLE AND PARTIES (POLITICAL) How People are Fooled

Filed under: Uncategorized — sharafs @ 6:35 am

parties

In 1999 General Pervez Musharraf received a proposal from a ‘fly by night reformer’ to make a political party of likeminded politicians. The proposal came to my desk in Military Operations for evaluation. I rejected it as a bad move because it proposed to promote a mind-set of intellectually corrupt politicians who are in fact a part and not solution to the problem. As time passed sanity was eclipsed by sycophants. I still maintain my thesis. When General Tanvir Naqvi took over as Chairman National Reconstruction Bureau, he sent over his Staff Officer to my office for some literature on National Reconstruction. I handed him ‘Pakistan: The Unstable State, Edited by Hassan Gardezi and Rashid Jamil. Later I received an acknowledgement call from the Chairman. Those interested in Pakistan’s political evolution must read this book.

Pakistanis glorify the role of Qaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah but ignore limitations time imposed on him to create a Nation. What followed is Inventive Nationalism based on debatable symbols. Many who joined the League did it for an interest and not a cause. Even today, many who join a popular party do it for an interest. Though a State and constitution exist, the Nation is confused, divided and politically inbreeding.

The politics of Muslim separatism had dark Trojans in feudal support from Punjab and rich businessmen from Bombay. The Pakistan that was visualised in the first session of the Constituent Assembly on 11 August 1947 is not the Pakistan that is. Pakistan’s political evolution is characterised by singular emphasis on preserving and perpetuation of elitist interests. With time, neo elitist, all-weather politicians and upstarts have joined the nexus. Constitutionalism laid guidelines and principals for a people centric social contract that was never put to practice. The first 40 Articles of the Constitution of Pakistan have never been enforced with the vigour they deserve. Six decades hence, nothing has changed.

In any democracy, political parties form the strongest link between the aspirations of the people and the state. Though much has been written on the nexus of Feudalism-Bureaucracy-Mullah-Military-Industrialists, political parties that formed the main staging grounds are often ignored. Every political party since 1947 is unrepresentative. Misguided people are made hostage to empty slogans. The biggest tragedy is that the oft maligned left that once represented the working classes is non-existent. Most of its leaders are now pseudo liberals.  

In 1937, All India Muslim League could win just two seats from Punjab and ultimately one defected to the feudal Unionists. This reflects how strong feudalism is. In 1945 majority was built on Christian Minority votes.  After the death of Qaid e Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the KHOTA SIKKAS galvanised the feudal-mullah alliance. Bureaucracy and military joined them. Ayub Khan’s decade of progress saw this club expand to feudal cum industrialists through award of preferential permits. Zia ul Haq continued the heist by gratifying select groups. During Musharraf’s tenure, a nouvelle generation of these cadres were inducted into cabinets that expanded their presence and influence within the system. Now they are all over, control Pakistan’s consumer economy, form strong cartels and influence good governance. Political parties of Pakistan are a tool of the chain.

According to a study by Omar Farooq Zain of Bahauddin Zakariya University, “political parties are a major ‘inputing’ device, allowing citizens to get their needs and wishes heard by the government. Without political parties, individuals would stand alone. Parties give people the feeling that they are not utterly powerless. In Pakistan, political parties have become a commodity that is readily available to the unconstitutional military rulers and non-representative elites for political manoeuvrings”. He is right because those in power continue to expand their space and deny others. Those out of power perform a peacock dance to attract the establishment. Internal culture of all major political parties is identical. The leftover from the 1935 Act that oversaw the interests of the viceroy continues to be the Achilles Heels of Pakistani politics. Unless this basic structure undergoes, nothing will change.

A glance at the evolution of Pakistan’s political parties has a pattern. Religious parties are backed and supported directly or indirectly by elites. All populist parties have a majority of elitists in higher echelons. They use their money, baradari linkages and the manipulative governance model (Thana and Patwari culture) effectively to manipulate electoral results. Fish rotting at the head is evident from the fact that some rising upstarts are actually police and patwari touts.

Even Bhutto’s (himself an educated feudal) populism was short lived. PPP was the first party that challenged with slogans of Islamic Socialism. Earlier than expected, the cadre of social revolutionaries and leftists was elbowed out by industrial and feudal classes. They rot in oblivion for giving up without a fight. The party still clings to these slogans during election campaigns. With the reign of massive corruptions and nepotism in its three tenures, the party is a reflection of the Orwellian Glass House that has nothing to offer to the sheep that follow it. Through NRO, it has combined with PMLN and its allies to pass constitutional amendments that facilitate corruption and violate the first three parts of the Constitution. Powers once enjoyed by the President under 58 (2) B have been passed on to party leaders who now wield an iron fist over their elected representatives that includes Chief Executives. If Shehla Raza of PPP is correct, the nation is yet to endure the trauma of NRO3 mastered by outside brokers. Surprisingly, PMLQ and MQM who now criticise the system were part of this daylight robbery of the Social Contract. MQM that rose as a challenger to these elitists has joined the glass house.

In any democratic system, political parties forge a crucial linkage between public demands and government support. They articulate this role within an inclusive political system that feels the public pulse, educates and organises its voters and evolves a political hierarchy intrinsically linked at all tiers as their surrogate. The leadership of parties revolves around specific roles for individuals with specific bench marks. The parties exercise internal accountability, democracy and a feedback loop that keeps their supporters linked. In chaotic times they act as public ventilators for change. In power, they become models of good governance.

But in Pakistan, the culture in political parties is opportunist. A long history of inventive nationalism and elitist politics produces leadership around a single individual who assumes an indispensable cultish stature. His word or logic is final. Charisma or clout of a leader is directly proportional to his ability to sway mass emotions with unquestionable obedience. The ‘know it all’ leader sets the agenda from the confines of the bubble he lives in.  He is followed by a group of ever green individuals who bash in his megalomaniac aura but represent elitism. They are chameleons that wait for their moment to strike. Fingers on the pulse of people, specified roles, training sessions, credible elections and bench marks are non-existent.

Effective separations of powers weaken elitist centrality. It introduces an inclusive political system and promotes populism. Local self-government the main engine of socio-economic and political growth and an inseparable part of the state is anathema to elites in political parties. They despise it.  For as long as Pakistan does not produce a true challenging class, neither the political parties nor the system will change?

Democracy in Pakistan will remain a farce as long as political parties and their leadership do not evolve.  

Brigadier (Retired) Samson Simon Sharaf is a political economist and a television anchorperson. Email and twitter: samson.sharaf@gmail.com

http://www.nation.com.pk/columns/26-Jul-2014/people-and-political-parties

Advertisements

Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: