INSIGHT AND FORESIGHT

August 24, 2014

CIVIL SOCIETY AND LIBERTIES

Filed under: Uncategorized — sharafs @ 6:40 am

10550965_682885768466525_7132298800491995172_n

It is déjà vu. The class struggle between the ‘Have Not’ and ‘Haves’ continues. They have endured the weather, trying conditions and long journeys in cramped vehicles for a dream. The past of 1970 is being repeated. The deep malaise of ruling elites is endemic and needs a strong medicine. Status quo political parties in denial of civil liberties are intransigent. If they cede, they fear the crumbling of politics whose edifice is built on an exploitative system that suits their interests. If they fight back, the peaceful protests could become violent and spread all over the country. Within this political turbulence, sceptics do not rule out an intervention by a third visible or invisible party. 

As events stand, the government is adopting a go-slow policy on inquesting and reforming an election system. The exercise of accountability would discredit their legitimacy and cease to put them in power through a process they master. Pro-democracy proponents in favour of sham democracy forget that fair and transparent elections are one part of democracy. The other aspect is empowering, reflecting and delivering the will of the people. Hence democrats of every description who wish to stand by the inertia are playing a negative role, history will never forget. 

Occupation of space by the state with no capability to administer has sucked people into many dark holes. These elites permeate administration at lowest level with Thanas, Patwaris and arm twisters. waderaism (fiefdoms), misuse of Madaris, drug and land mafias, marketing cartels, currency operators, private armies, militancy and Gullu Butts are a reflection. The Trojan of a mind-set with insatiable capability to permeate and control any movement is fast multiplying. The fault and notoriety of Imran Khan and Dr Qadri is that they are challenging it.  

The civil society of Pakistan that bears the primary responsibility for rights of civil liberties is mysteriously quiet since the 80s. It came to life for the wrong reasons in the restoration of the Chief Justice. As events prove, General Musharraf was right. The so called independent judiciary has not delivered for the rights of the people who swarmed streets during the movement, died, got wounded and endured jails. The judiciary made life exclusively miserable for the PPP government for five years. They impeded and obstructed transparency in the system. The suo moto were one sided. The apex courts remained suspiciously quiet on issues of public interests and civil rights.   

Civil Society demonstrates democratic activity outside the ambit of the state machinery. In political science philosophers like Georg Hegel and the revolutionary theorist Karl Marx, called them an inclusive concept of ‘society minus the state’. In the twentieth century the development of civil society is seen as a significant criterion of the development of democracy. In each culture, civil society is a reflection of the traditions, conventions and codes of behaviour outside the legal hierarchal structure of the state. Even as I write, a civil rights disobedience movement continues in Ferguson, St. Louis USA. 

Civil Society is the epitome of National Power and what Hans Morgenthau calls the ‘Sweeping opportunities of National Character and Morale’. It appears the civil society of Pakistan has resigned itself to the fold of the 60% masses who do not participate in elections. Either they do not have the desire to be counted or resign themselves to petty gratifications that come their way. There are no active labour and trade unions, no effective civil rights groups, no student movements, no revolutionary poets like Faiz, Faraz, Jalib, Daman and Munir Niazi. Pseudo Liberals living off NGOs and grants fail to realise that the fight for civil liberties is always fought on the streets to pressurise the legislature and executive in the right direction. 

All India Muslim League grew out of the Mohamadden Education Movement, itself a civil society organisation. In a resource starved post 1947 Pakistan, it was mostly the civic organisations that took on the onerous tasks of rehabilitating refugees, running education institutions and promoting egalitarianism. Even today, it is the civil society that remains the most vibrant and effective means of relief. 

The role of village panchaits, jirgas, joint community care, and collective participation in celebrations and mourning are aspects that are still practised.  In Pakistan, multiple inheritances give rise to unresolved struggles between the practices and values of authoritarian legacies and democratic aspirations. Post colonialism a new class of neo colonialists has emerged with an exclusive fiefdom of its own. Governments once elected forget their legislative functions to expand space into the executive. In Pakistan, all elections represent an inclusive strain, but once done, governments recluse themselves to an exclusive domain. Workers who accomplish all the donkey work are ignored. The present government calls it the loser while President Zardari used to refer to them as political jokers. The result is a complete disconnect from the constituencies. 

The massive sit-ins on the constitutional avenue cannot be dismissed as unconstitutional and power politics. These are demands of two political parties that focus exclusively on civil liberties.  It is a reaction to the suffocation within a rigged legislature that refuses to bridge the gap between the people and state and holds fundamental rights of its citizens in abeyance for its vested interests. 

The struggle can no more be described an agitation by particular groups to wrest political power unconstitutionally. The call is for complete transparency. It is a desire and aspiration to truly empower the people and bring meaning to the sanctity of the ballot and power to the people as enunciated in the constitution. This has remained the missing link ever since Qaid E Azam laid out Pakistan’s social contract with people on 11 August 1947.

The civil society needs to galvanise and throw up new leadership capable of exerting relentless pressure on the government and political parties. The silent majority has to venture out of their homes.  People need to reoccupy space they have ceded. The success of this movement depends on the people. If they come out and be counted, the wide gulf between the people and the state may be bridged in future. If they do not, a cause would have been lost to exploitative politics.

Those who are unwilling to join this Civil Liberties Campaign have to do so vociferously. Keyboard revolutionaries should never ever criticise the system. They will live in captivity for a century. 

Brigadier (Retired) Samson Simon Sharaf is a political economist and a television anchorperson. Email and twitter: samson.sharaf@gmail.com

http://www.nation.com.pk/columns/23-Aug-2014/civil-society-and-liberties

 

Advertisements

Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: